Alyra, I sat down to dinner on Saturday intending to eat, and instead a man explained to me how he walks between worlds, and I did not touch my food.
The red flower
Panlan was there. You know Panlan a little from my letters and not nearly enough. I asked him how shadow walking works, and he warned me the simple version would be much more complicated than it sounded, and then gave me the simple version, and I have not been able to put it down since.
Imagine you are on a road, and ahead of you it bends into a forest, and you cannot see round the bend.
And you know — you KNOW, you do not hope, you do not guess — that when you come round that bend there will be a red flower blooming in the middle of the road. It was not there when you walked that way before. It is there now. You believe it entirely.
And you come round the bend, and the flower is there.
And the forest is not quite as thick as it was.
You are not on Evren any more. You are on a shadow of Evren, very close to it.
That is all it is, he says. You do that again, and again, and each change takes you a little further from where you started, and if you keep going in increments you can arrive at whatever plane, or whatever shadow of your own, you were trying to reach.
Alyra. It is the calmest description of an impossible thing I have ever been given. There is no gesture in it. There is no word of power. There is a man on a road being certain about a flower.
The long way to nowhere
Then I asked how he LEARNED it, and the answer stopped being calm.
To learn it you have to walk to nowhere. Not any nowhere — a specific one.
So he walked. He made small changes as he went, the way he described: a forest, and then the trees are shorter, and then there are fewer of them, and then over the next hill there are none at all and it is grass, and then the grass is shorter. He kept taking things away. The land went barren and broken and dry. Then there was nothing on the horizon. Then there was no horizon. Then there was no road in front of him.
And then he took one more step, and everything was dark.
You have to trust it, he said. If you are wrong, you are done. So you have to be right.
And when you take that step, and you find you are standing on something, and you turn to look back — there is nothing behind you either. You cannot step back. You have to keep going, because if you stop, you are nowhere.
So you keep walking. And then you start ADDING. A pinprick of light. Another one. Stars. And eventually he arrived at the particular nowhere he had been aiming at all along, which was a hub of the followers of D’Tangier — a place he had once reached through a portal, and where he had been told that the only way to learn is to get there yourself.
If he had come out in the wrong place he would have arrived in The Graveyard, which he has heard about, and from which you do not come back.
The more you do it the easier it becomes and the larger the changes you can make. If you are very good you can take other people with you, but that is enormously harder, because you are not only changing your own reality — you have to change theirs for them, on their behalf, while they are standing in it.
He also said that most people who learn it had a leaning toward it already, and that if the whole process feels alien or frightening to you, you will probably never manage it.
I asked myself, quietly, in my own head, whether it feels alien or frightening to me.
I am not going to write down the answer.
The same thing, said worse
Here is why I love this job.
Earlier that same day, Legible had told me about shadow walking too, and his version was: get drunk, put on a blindfold, and start walking. He said this was an exaggeration but not entirely wrong — that it is a chaotic crapshoot, that you can become very good at it, and that becoming very good at it would require you to unnaturally extend your lifespan and then devote serious study to the problem. He also said that if Panlan told him this was how he got about, he would believe it completely, not because it is the most sensible way to travel but because it fits Panlan.
He drew a distinction I have been thinking about since. Shadow walking is you going somewhere. But a man called Lord Michael — Shadow Hands, they call him — does not go anywhere. He reaches ACROSS the planes and pulls what he wants toward him. Legible said: imagine one of those long grabbing tools, the kind for picking things off high shelves. Now imagine one the length of a field. Now get blind drunk, put the blindfold on, and use it to pick up a milk bottle. Five centimetres off and you have picked up a person instead.
And then he said the line I actually wrote down, which is that there are a great many worse things you can reach for, and some of them will pick YOU up.
Two men. Two descriptions. Same act. One made it sound like faith and one made it sound like a drunk with a grabber, and neither of them was lying, and I have both versions in the book side by side because I think you learn more from the pair than from either.
The guild
Panlan heads the Wizards Guild. He says “ostensibly,” which I have noted, because a man who runs something and calls it ostensibly is telling you something.
It covers most of the DISCIPLINES. There is a discipline for spirit, one for nature, one for the arcane. Necromancy is its own affair, because it was illegal in Varos for a very long time and the necromancers grew up outside it.
And then there are the BRANCHES, which are not disciplines at all but places — actual halls of the wizard school, in actual towns. When another branch opened, Panlan decided that as the man in charge he needed lackeys to run them. So he has lackeys, and their names are Lapis and Pyramus.
I am being careful about those two words because I was not careful at the table, and for a good while I thought a branch and a discipline were the same thing and nodded along at a sentence I had stopped following. A discipline is a kind of magic. A branch is a building with somebody in it. If you are ever in that guild, establish which one a person means before you agree with them.
The guild has yearly dues, and what the dues buy is membership, access to the ritual library, and a discount if you need a ritual cast.
Panlan’s own assessment: the guild is much more of an idol now than a functioning thing. It largely runs itself. Direct intervention is very rarely needed.
It does supply wards, which is why he is the man everyone chases for ward keys. (Alyra, I am aware that I am carrying a ward key that is not mine. I am aware of it constantly. Moving on.)
Celadon’s policy
Separately — and I want it clear that this is its own piece of business and not part of anything above — Celadon was selling insurance at that table. Genuinely, for a gold. Three plans.
The policy includes a rift OUT if things go badly.
Out to where, I asked.
That is the part the policy does not specify. You do not choose the destination. It will not be the situation you are currently in. It may or may not be better than the situation you are currently in.
Lady Silver’s contribution was to ask that nobody select her estate as a recall point, because the black frogs will not have been told you are coming and will treat your arrival as a live fire drill.
It is on my list to go and meet the frogs.
Colouring sheets
Then I asked the question I had been saving all day: what is the difference between chaos magic and wild magic? Are they two names for one thing?
They are not, and Panlan explained it with colouring sheets, and it is the best explanation of magic anybody has ever given me.
Arcane, spirit and nature magic — the magic with rules, and formulae, and a written language — is a colouring sheet. Here is the picture. Here are the lines. Colour it in. The lines are there to keep the thing pointed where you meant it.
Wild magic is the same colouring sheet handed to an artist nobody told to stay inside the lines. You still have the picture. You get a slightly different effect.
Chaos magic is a blank sheet of paper. Colour your fire engine. It is enormously malleable, and sometimes you are trying for Y and you get Z. Panlan says that when you are GOOD at chaos magic you can produce the effects you need and control it to a degree — that you may never do the same thing the same way twice, but you can get the same result twice. I would like you to notice how much work the word “good” is doing there.
And then there is pattern magic, which is colour by number. You will colour it the colour that was determined for you, or you will not colour it at all.
Pattern magic, he says, was used in founding the schools of magic everyone uses today. It is what put the structure INTO magic in the first place.
He does not know anybody who practises it now. The last person he knew who did was Pyramus.
The theory I brought to the table, and what happened to it
I had a theory, Alyra. I had been carrying it around since the afternoon and I was quite pleased with it.
Legible had told me that the old writing on the pen was dead, and ancient, and notoriously ambiguous — that the same mark could mean two things. The modern glyphs are precise because somebody deliberately made them precise. So I asked Panlan: might the old ambiguous language be connected to chaos magic? Might learning one be part of learning the other? Is that a connection point?
Panlan said: probably not.
I am writing that down exactly as it happened, because it is the whole reason I do this the way I do. It was a good-looking theory. It fitted. It joined two things I had learned on the same day into one satisfying shape, and satisfying shape is precisely the thing I have to be most careful of.
The pattern-magic answer is duller and more likely, and duller and more likely is usually the way of it.
What I did not get to
That is the dinner, Alyra, and it is the half of the evening that happened sitting down.
The other half happened on water, and I am giving it its own pages, because it is a different kind of night entirely and because putting the two together would make the flower and the fish share a room, which neither of them deserves.
Tomorrow, then. There is a boat in it, and a cave, and I acquit myself in a way I did not expect to have to defend.
Leave a Reply