Alyra, I promised you this one, and I have taken three days over it, and I want to explain why before I start.
It is not a fact. It is a STORY, and I have been trying to work out how to put a story in a book.
My first attempt was very tidy. I had it in order — here is the factory, here is the toy, here is the man, here is what happened to him — and it read beautifully and it was WRONG, because that is not how I got it. Legible did not tell it in order. He told it backwards, and sideways, and he went round twice in places, and he forgot the beginning entirely until I asked.
And the more I looked at my tidy version the more I thought: I have thrown away the only part of this that is evidence.
So here it is in his order, with me in the margins where I was. The shape is his. The interruptions are mine, and I have left the worst of mine in.
He started at the end
The first thing out of his mouth — no factory, no toy, no name, nothing — was this:
I just sit in front of this woman and tell her that her husband died in a fist fight with a squeaky dog toy.
I want to be clear that I had no idea what he was talking about. Neither did anybody else at the table. He was ten minutes past the beginning of a story he had not started.
I said something about what the underwriters must make of that, which I thought was quite good.
And he stopped, and looked round at all of us, and realised none of us had it. And then he said — and it went on for some time — “you didn’t. Nobody told you about this. I don’t think. Oh. Oh my. All right. Okay.”
And started again.
The foreman is a squeaky dog toy
He has a factory. Kobolds work it. It makes screws, and candles, and — his phrasing, waved off — don’t ask.
The foreman of that factory sits on a stool in the middle of the floor and gives the orders, and he is a squeaky dog toy.
Here is the part he explained first, because he wanted us to understand the mechanism before anything else happened:
I’ll watch a kobold walk behind him and squeak him as he walks past. The other kobolds think he’s talking.
And then, because he could see us not believing him: I’m not making this up. We can go down to the factory right now, I’ll show you.
He then argued himself out of it, out loud, in front of us — it was a holiday, no, it was a shift change, they would not be out for two hours — and by the end of it he had talked himself into staying in his chair and telling us instead.
Alyra, that was the first moment I thought: he has done this before.
The fight, which he told as an argument with himself
He does not narrate. He interrogates. He asks himself the questions we were about to ask and then answers them in a different voice, and it moves very fast:
And Squeakers says some shit to him. This is how I heard the story. What did he say? Doesn’t matter what he said. Of course it does. Then what happened? Well, the kobold got indignant. Right, he’s a kobold. Of course he got indignant. That’s just kind of a default state for kobold.
I said the only thing available to a man in my position, which was that his attorney had reported to him that a squeaking toy was getting LIPPY, and that this seemed a strong claim for a thing with no lips.
He did not take that well. He defended the lawyer at once — a man he pays a great deal to keep on retainer, a damn good attorney, the man who tells him the factual details of the accounts of the people involved.
And then he went on.
The worker said: all right, foreman, let’s take this outside.
And he went to the stairs, and turned round, and the foreman was still sitting on his stool.
Still sitting there. Can’t get up and move, just to be clear.
You are not man enough, said the worker. And the accounts say that at this point the foreman told him where to go.
The gold on Schmidt’s table
I need to stop here and explain something about how this story is built, because it took me most of the evening to understand what I was hearing.
Legible was not there. He did not see any of this. Everything he has, he has because he sent his attorney down onto that factory floor to find out — and so what he is really telling us, all the way through, is the story of SITTING ACROSS A TABLE FROM SCHMIDT AND BEING TOLD.
And as the account got worse, he kept pushing more gold across it.
A hundred at the taunt on the stairs — “he’s not getting paid enough for this.” Two hundred by the middle of it. A thousand by the end. And at one point, when the lawyer had stopped volunteering and Legible wanted the next part anyway:
Put another chit on the table. Keep telling me.
Alyra, that is not a fee. Nobody agreed a rate and nobody was invoiced. That is a man realising, in real time and one revelation at a time, what he had asked another man to go and wade through on his behalf — and having nothing to offer him for it except more money, which he knew perfectly well was not the right thing to offer.
I have been turning that over since. If you want to know how bad a thing was, you could do worse than ask what it cost the person who had to go and find out.
What the man did
He went up to the second-storey walkway and came off it elbow-first, like a wrestler, into a room full of furnaces.
He missed entirely.
Like you ever see a guy try to do a dive off a high dive and instead belly-flop onto the concrete? That was this kobold.
Landed head first. Shattered his elbow in — Legible’s figure, and he hedged it himself — something like seventeen places.
I said that this is what happens when you jump from two storeys. He took the feed and ran with it and we were both quite pleased with ourselves, and I am recording that because it is the last enjoyable thing in the whole account.
He got up and accused the foreman of fighting dirty.
The foreman, the entire time this is happening, stone cold killer face.
Then he turned his back to rally the floor behind him — and here Legible acted out the arm, which by this stage of the story does not work any more, and I will not attempt to put that on a page — and from behind him the foreman called him a coward.
So he swung. With an arm hanging on, Legible said, by three tendons and an artery. Missed. Hit himself in the gut — he corrected himself mid-sentence there, he had said jaw first and went back for gut, and you will see in a moment why gut is the better word — and then accused the foreman of hitting below the belt.
I observed that below the belt is not a large target on a kobold.
He observed that it is also not reachable from a stool.
Schmidt, level with me
And then he stopped the story entirely, and did the scene I would keep if I could keep only one thing from the whole weekend.
His attorney’s name is Schmidt. Thirty years. Legible put gold on the table and asked him — and he did the voice, both voices, his own pleading and Schmidt’s flat and unmoving —
Schmidt, level with me. Please tell me somebody walked behind that squeaky toy and squeezed it when the guy’s back was turned.
And Schmidt looks me dead in the eyes and goes: Legible. I don’t know. I just don’t know, man.
He asked four times over the course of the evening. He got the same answer four times. By the end he was saying it in Schmidt’s voice himself without being asked, as a kind of punctuation.
He offered to write a note of hand, because he was out of gold in his pockets. He offered dinner. Schmidt did not want any of it.
The attorney did not want the money. He just wanted to tell me the rest of the story. That’s how bad this got.
Alyra, that is an ARCHIVE. That is what one looks like when it is built by a man who did not want to build it, about a thing he wanted to come out differently, by an investigator who would not round the answer off to make his client feel better.
And Schmidt kept telling him. There is no strings, Schmidt said. There is no marionette. It just sat there.
Into the furnace
The man swung again. Missed again. Tripped, got tangled in the stool, and went down a flight of stairs into the pit where the furnaces are — and the stool and the foreman went with him. Off a bulkhead, off a railing, and then onto the back of the man’s head.
Squeaking on both impacts.
At which point the man believed he was being taken from behind.
There is a passage after this that I cannot give you, because Legible could not give it to me either. Something about the toy and the man’s foot. He asked Schmidt what he meant, and Schmidt started to explain, and Legible stopped him:
He doesn’t want to tell me, and I don’t want to know.
Then the man lost his footing, and went onto the conveyor, and into the furnace, and the door shut.
He came back OUT of the furnace, on fire, and tackled the foreman, who had by this point apparently become fireproof.
I don’t understand. I stopped asking questions.
Then over the railing into the firebox again, and out of it, and onto the ground.
All he had to do was stand up
Cause of death was want of air. It is nothing but bad air at the bottom of that pit.
No broken bones below the sternum. His legs were fine. His feet were fine.
He never lost consciousness.
All he had to do was stand up.
And he did not stand up, and Legible knows why, because he made Schmidt find out.
He stayed on the ground because he was showing submission. He was acknowledging that he had lost the fight.
Alyra, I have written that sentence four times now and it has not got any smaller.
Fifty on the floor, forty-eight telling it
I want the sourcing in here, because the sourcing is the reason I believe any of it.
There are fifty kobolds on that floor. Schmidt went down and interviewed everybody. Forty-eight of them told the story, or a variation of it.
Legible’s own gloss:
Either there’s some real good collusion going on, or this is a somewhat accurate to life tale.
He did not decide which. He told us both and left it standing.
The forty-ninth
And then I did the sum, Alyra, and I have not been able to leave it alone since.
Fifty kobolds on that floor.
One of them is dead.
Forty-eight of them gave Schmidt an account.
That leaves one.
Somewhere in that factory there is a kobold who was there, who is alive, and who told the investigator nothing. Thirty years of practice at getting people to talk. A man sitting across a table pushing gold at the problem until there was a thousand of it. Forty-eight of his colleagues lining up to say their piece.
And one who did not.
I want to be careful here, because I can feel myself enjoying this too much. I am doing ARITHMETIC, not investigation. I am assuming the fifty includes the man who died, and Legible did not actually say that — if the fifty were the living, then everyone but two spoke and there is nothing here at all.
I asked nobody about it. It did not occur to me until I was writing this out, which is becoming a habit I dislike.
But if I have it right: forty-eight people will happily tell you what they saw a squeaky toy do.
The forty-ninth is the one I want.
What do I say to this woman
And then he came back round to the line he had opened with, an hour before, and I understood that the whole thing had been a circle.
What do I say to her, he asked Schmidt. Give me a script. What do I say?
And Schmidt wrote him one, and he read it out to us in a completely flat voice:
I am sorry, and I lament and regret the loss and the suffering that you must be experiencing.
That is a lawyer’s sentence. Every word of it is doing legal work. And he read it to a widow because he genuinely did not know what else to say.
Something like three thousand gold to the lawyers, in the end — his figure, and he waved a hand when he said it, so take it as the size of the thing rather than the sum of it.
One gold and five silver
She asked for one gold and five silver.
He set it up deliberately. One fifty, he said. Not a hundred and fifty gold. One gold, five silver. He has told it that way before; you can hear the join.
The gold was for emotional damages. The five silver was for the urn.
Her husband had been cremated in the course of dying, which saved a step.
She did not pay the five silver. Legible did not charge her for the urn.
And then he went up, and up, and up — take all the candles you like, he told her, build your house out of candles; I will school your children TWICE, and I do not mean two days, I mean two entire educations, back to back; can they live at the school, not to the end of the year, I mean for ever.
I said something about the children perhaps needing twice. He talked straight over me. He was not really in the room for that part.
And then, quietly:
I’ve gotten better about it since I told you guys about it. I don’t have that overwhelming anger any more.
Alyra, he said that out loud. He told us he has told this before, to these same people, and that he has improved with practice.
Which explains the polish, and it also explains the places where the polish runs out.
And then I asked where it came from
Here is the part that undid my tidy version.
Twenty minutes in, with the man dead and the widow paid and the lawyers settled, somebody asked him how any of this started — and only THEN did he tell us where the foreman came from.
He had the toy in his pocket. He was at the factory, he needed to get a pen out, so he put the toy down on a stool and forgot it. Somebody had given it to him.
He came back the next day and there was a small pinned paper badge on it that said FOREMAN.
I was like, oh, that’s funny. That’s a cute little mascot. I like that. I’ll leave him here for morale.
A week later the manager told him the workers were on strike.
Why, said Legible.
Because we are not paying the foreman enough.
The WHO, said Legible.
And the manager explained, patiently, that Legible had hired a foreman. Legible asked who. The manager did not know. Some raccoon fellow, he thought.
Then the two of them worked out the raise, and this is the most constructed sentence in the entire evening, and I am giving it to you exactly:
All right, so give them a hundred per cent raise.
Legible. They’re smarter than that.
They are taking orders from a squeaky toy. They are not, in fact, smarter than that. I promise.
Turns out they were, in fact, smarter than that.
A hundred per cent of nothing, Alyra. Twice nothing.
The foreman now earns three fried potatoes a week, up from one and a half. Legible does not know how the potatoes started — his best guess is that a kobold walked past with lunch, dropped some, and another kobold concluded they were the foreman’s.
And the workers get upset if he gives the foreman four.
I said what anybody at that table would have said: they would not want a large wage imbalance between the workers and their manager.
The things that are not jokes
If the foreman is absent, production falls by half. That is not a figure of speech and Legible does not tell it as one. He forgot to bring him in one morning and lost half the day. He has tried substitutes. A small porcelain cat: nothing. A different dog toy: nothing.
I asked whether he had ever tried changing the squeaker to a different sound.
He was appalled with me. They would think he had had an OPERATION.
He also gets six weeks of holiday a year — more, Legible complains, than Legible gets — and when he takes it a substitute has to be found.
Where the joke is
And then, near the end, the shape of the telling changed. The polish came off it. He was just a man talking.
You know what scares me about this? I think it’s possible that they do, in fact, know he’s a squeaky toy.
I said: but they take orders from him anyway.
He said yes.
Somebody offered him the tidier version — that fifty kobolds are running a conspiracy on their own employer, keeping a joke going for years — and he turned it over and put it down, because one of them is dead.
I’m all for committing to the joke. But dead by want of air at the bottom of his own pit — and I promise you, they didn’t fake his death.
And then he said the thing I have not been able to put down since:
I don’t know where the joke is any more. It’s a funny story, but I’m just not sure where the joke is.
He did not finish
I want this in the record too, because it is a fact about the telling and not about the factory.
He did not end it. He complained for a moment that the foreman gets more time off than he does, and observed that he does not even sign his own accountant’s payments and should look into that, and mangled a metaphor about hammers and nails and then defended the mangle — and then he stopped mid-thought, said “sorry, not about the foreman,” and started talking about something else entirely.
There was no ending. He simply ran out.
I have been an archivist for two years and I have never had a source do that to me. Everybody gives you an ending. They round it off, they land it, they tell you what it meant. He got to the bottom of it and found there was nothing there to land on, and changed the subject.
So that is the shape, Alyra: he began at the woman, worked forwards through the death, paid his way through it in gold, arrived at the settlement, was ASKED where it all came from, went back to the beginning, came forward again to the strike — and then walked off the end of it.
I have written it down the way I got it, because I think the way I got it is the true part.
Three disclaimers, if you want to know how it went for him. Early on: I’m not making this up. In the middle: I’m not making any of this up. And near the end, after the potatoes:
I wish I was making this up. I really do. It’d be funnier to me if I was.
Leave a Reply