Alyra, I need to tell you about the rest of that night, and I need to tell you carefully, because I am not sure I have ever been so out of my depth while sitting perfectly still.
It was very late. The fighting had been over for hours. The lanterns had got down to that stage where they are the only warm thing left in the world, and there were four of us at a table in the dark: Felix, Toh, Thoral, and me with the book open and my hand already tired.
And then one of them came and sat down with us.
One. Not a pack. He came out of the same dark that had been full of teeth and laughing three hours earlier, and he pulled up to our table like a man joining a card game, and he did not attack anybody.
He… whispered.
I have sat with that word for two days and it is still not right, Alyra, and I want to tell you why rather than pick a tidier one. They do not SPEAK. Not the way you and I speak, not the way I am writing this. Whatever a Fenrae does when it wants you to know something, it is not the thing a mouth does. It arrives quiet and it arrives close and it is under the noise rather than over it.
And we understood him. Every word of it. Four of us, all at once, no confusion about any of it.
I have no better account than that and I am not going to invent one. Whispered is the nearest word I own.
Here is what it cost me, though, and it is the first thing you need to know about that night: it was ALL like that. The whole conversation, hours of it, pitched down under the lanterns. My notes from it are the worst notes I have ever taken and the most important ones, and there are gaps in them I am never going to be able to fill.
He went for Felix first.
He put it to Felix that Felix is a traitor to his order. Felix answered him — well, and at length, and to my ear he had the better of it. The shape of it is this, and the shape belongs to everybody at that table: whether a man who swore an oath to the VIRTUES of a thing is still bound to the thing once the virtues have gone out of it. Felix says no binding. Our visitor says traitor.
And then, in the middle of making that case, Felix reached for an example.
Felix turned to Thoral — here is a man who knows a great deal about oaths — and asked him: would you call me a traitor? And then he put the parallel, and the parallel was Thoral’s own oath, and what it has cost him.
I am not going to write down the parallel. You will see why in a moment.
Alyra, my pen was already moving. I said something about wanting to be sure I had it down right in the ledger.
And somebody said: don’t put that.
And Felix said: no, this is off the record. And I am not trying to deflect onto Thoral. I am simply stating.
So it is off the record. That is all you get, and that is all anybody gets.
And I want you to notice WHAT Felix took back, because I did not notice it until I was writing this and it has changed how I feel about the whole evening. He was not protecting himself. He had been defending himself out loud and at volume for ten minutes and he never once asked me to leave any of that out. What he pulled off the record was the part that was not his — the part about the man sitting next to him, and that man’s oath. He reached for it because it made his argument, and then he heard himself, and he took it back.
You will understand why I am honouring it. On Friday night a friend of mine told me he would rather not have been written about, and I have been carrying that around like a stone in my boot ever since. But this is not even the same thing. I am not being asked to keep a man’s private business out of a letter. I am being asked not to publish a THIRD man’s private business, which a second man mentioned by accident, in front of a creature that may very well have sat down at that table to collect exactly that.
And then, the fence having gone up and everybody having stepped back over it, they went on.
Our visitor asked Felix the question that I think was the real one all along, and he asked it quite gently: did you swear an oath to the king, or did you swear an oath to the land?
And Felix said — and this was not off the record, and I checked, because I have learned to check —
He was my friend for a long time. He taught me a lot of what I knew, in the past life.
But that secret exists.
Alyra, I put my pen down for a second at that.
I had been listening to an argument about oaths as though it were an argument about oaths. Institutions and virtues and bindings and whether a promise survives the thing it was made to. And underneath all of it was a man who had loved somebody, and been taught by him, and left.
That is not a smaller story than the one I thought I was recording. It is the actual size of it, and everything else is the shape people put round it so it can be said out loud at a table.
I did not ask what the secret is. I want to be clear that I WANTED to. He told me plainly that there is one — which is a thing I have noticed people only do when some part of them would like it found — and I wrote down that a secret exists and I did not go after it, and that is the second time in one conversation I have had to decide what kind of archivist I am.
I am going to say plainly that this is MY reading and not a fact I collected: I think they were arguing about two different objects and neither of them noticed. Felix was talking about what he swore to. Our visitor was talking about what he swore ON. Write that down as Ledger’s opinion, Alyra, and no better than that.
And then this Fenrae turned to Thoral.
And he was cruel about it, and he was cruel in the specific way that makes you realise the cruelty was researched. He asked Thoral question after question, and every one of them was aimed. He said betrayal is terrible, isn’t it, Thoral. Am I right, Thoral. Am I right.
I am not going to set down what he asked, either. It is the same ground and it is not mine to till.
What I will set down is this, because it is a fact about the creature and not about Thoral: he did not have to look for the sore place. He went to it directly, in under a minute, having been at that table for a matter of hours.
I have been turning that over ever since and I cannot get it to a conclusion. I have three readings and I am going to give you all three, in the order I thought of them, which is not the order of how likely they are.
The first is dull and is probably the right one. A thing that has been alive fourteen thousand cycles has presumably learned to find the tender spot in any room it sits down in. That is not sinister. That is just practice.
The second is that he was handed a direction, thirty seconds earlier, by a man who tried immediately to take it back.
And the third one I did not think of until yesterday, and it is the one I cannot put down.
He came to that table for Thoral.
Not for Felix. Not for Toh, and certainly not for me. He sat down, and he spent his opening on the man beside Thoral, and he took the long way round through an argument about oaths — and every step of that road ended up somewhere it was always going to end up. On that reading, Felix was not the target. Felix was the DOOR.
I have one thing that leans that way and I am going to give it to you and let you weigh it yourself: when he finally named the thing he means to ask for — and you will hear about the favour in a moment, because there is a favour — it pointed the same direction. Not the same words. The same direction.
I do not know which of the three it is. I am recording that I do not know. But I want it noticed what the three of them are, because the difference between them is the difference between an old creature, a briefed one, and one that arrived with a name in its mouth and worked patiently round the table until it got there.
And I had nothing. I want that in the record too — the archivist sat there with the whole book open in front of him and had NOTHING, because I do not know the answer, and because the man beside me who does know it has not told me and is entitled not to.
So I wrote down the questions instead. Sometimes the questions are the artefact.
And then the Fenrae turned to Toh, and we were there for an hour, and I still do not think I have got to the bottom of it.
It started as a gift. He gave Toh astrology. Not the fortune-telling kind — the mechanical kind, how time is counted where he comes from. Twelve signs in the zodiac; the passage of Discordia through all twelve is one solar year; twelve zodiac cycles in a year. And the astrology of every plane is DIFFERENT, because it is set by that plane’s relationship to Discordia, and the planes drift closer to one another and further apart on a cycle of their own.
I asked which direction Discordia is in. He told me it is not in a direction. It is in a different plane.
I asked how long he had been alive. He said fourteen thousand and thirty-seven cycles of the zodiac that we use — and he was quite pointed about the “that we use”, because he had to do the conversion himself, and he wanted the effort noticed. That works out at rather more than a thousand years and I would like you to sit with that for a moment, because I have been, off and on, ever since.
Then he told me, without any particular malice, that I am entirely unfamiliar with my own zodiac.
Reader, he was right. I have not the faintest idea what beast I was born under. I have written pages on the calendars of a dead city and I cannot tell you my own sign. It is on the list. It is genuinely on the list, I put it on the list in front of him, and he watched me do it, and I think he enjoyed that more than anything else he got out of me all night.
And THEN, having given the gift, he asked Toh for his name in return.
Toh declined.
And here is the part I have been turning over. He did not press. He did not sulk. He said — and I am as near to his words as my notes allow — that a name would have been far too large a payment for so small a gift. That he could not have compelled Toh to give it, because the trade was not proportional, and that this is exactly why he only asked.
Toh said he does not believe in owing favours. He said it plainly and he said it several times and he said it well.
Alyra, I have never watched anybody lose an argument so thoroughly while being so completely right.
Because our visitor’s answer was this: belief has nothing to do with it. A favour owed is not an entry in a ledger — he said the word ledger looking directly at me, and I will admit that it stung — and it is not a debt, and it is not credit, and there is no accounting. It is a FACT that exists between two people, and it cannot exist without both of them. And when he chooses to call it in, the one who owes will have no more choice about complying than a man has about becoming angry when you find the right insult for him. You do not have to believe in becoming angry. You will still become angry. That was his whole case, and he made it about nine different ways, and I could not find the crack in it.
He gave us a farmer. Your neighbour’s crop fails and yours booms and you feed him through the winter, and you may say you expect nothing, but if he robbed you in the spring you would be angrier than if you had never fed him at all. That extra anger, he said, is the shape of the thing. That is the favour. It was there the whole time.
He said this is why favours cannot be handed on to somebody else — not because of some rule, but because the other person was not part of the interaction and has no way of seeing it.
He said the Fae of this land, with their magistrates and their courts and their contracts, are not true Fae, and that their courts do not arbitrate at all: they SENTENCE. They can impose a penalty and they cannot touch the truth of who owes what. He said the Evren Fae built courts because they never learned how to do the other thing. I am not qualified to say whether that is true. I am only qualified to say he believes it in his bones, and that he expects us to see him prove it, because he told us that when he calls in his favour we will all watch it happen.
Somebody at the table — I think it was Felix — said: Ledger. You need that pen.
You remember the pen. I told you about it, I speculated about it, I have been carrying the idea around like a lucky coin: a pen that writes only what is true. So I asked him. Could a pen write down somebody’s true name?
He said no.
He said that to be Fae you must know your name and be able to SAY it, and that knowing and speaking are the same act — if you cannot speak it, you do not know it. Names are spoken. They are not written. They are audio, he said, and they always have been, and there is nothing you can do on a page that carries a word in all the ways a voice carries it. A pen cannot tell you anyone’s name, because a pen cannot speak.
And then, to Felix: your true name is not Felix. If it were, I could compel you with it.
I wrote that down twice, Alyra. Once because it is important and once because I wanted to be doing something with my hands.
There is one more exchange and then I will let you go. Somewhere in all of it Felix asked him the only question I actually needed answered: why are you here NOW?
He said: a lucrative offer was made.
I want to set that beside something else, and I want to set it there without smoothing it out. Earlier that same night, in the middle of the fighting, Rom told me the Fenrae are here because they are cursed, and angry, and because they are being FORCED.
Forced, says one. Paid, says the other. Both of those came to me firsthand, from people who were there, on the same night, about the same creatures. I do not know which is true. It is possible both are true and they apply to different Fenrae, or that one of them was lying to me, which is a thing that people do and which I should probably start assuming more often than I do. What I am not going to do is pick the one that makes the tidier sentence.
At the very end I asked him whether there was a noun he would like us to call him by.
He said no.
And then he said: I am nothing if not honest.
So in my book he is Honest. He named himself by refusing to, which I suspect he would find funny, and he told us a very great deal about how his people work, and gave away one small piece of astrology, and left holding a favour from a friend of mine that none of us knows the size of yet.
He is going to come and collect it, Alyra. He said so.
I would like to be somewhere else when he does, and I know perfectly well that I will be standing right there with the book open.
The eyes, which I did not write down
One more thing, and it is the worst of them, and I only found it going back over the night afterwards.
You know what the eyes mean. Everybody here does. A Fenrae’s glow tells you what you are standing in front of — nothing at all at the bottom, then colours, and white at the very top.
Earlier that same night, when they came out of the dark at us, I saw red. I wrote it down. I was quite pleased with myself for getting it into the book while a fight was going on around me.
And then, at the table, before I had properly begun — before the oaths, before the astrology, before any of it — somebody looked at our visitor and said out loud that his eyes were purple.
I did not write it down.
Alyra, I want you to feel the size of that. I filled pages that night. I have his cycles to the year. I have his zodiac, and his farmer, and his courts, and his position on what a name is and why a pen cannot hold one. And the one measurement in the room that I did not have to ask anybody for — that was handed to me free, in the first breath of the evening, by somebody else who had noticed it on my behalf — went straight past me.
So. Honest is a colour. Not nothing, and not white.
Where purple falls between those two I do not know, and I would like to, because a thing fourteen thousand cycles old that is not at the top of its own scale is a far more interesting thing than one that is.
I could have known that before he opened his mouth.
Put it in the book and put it plainly, because a record that only holds the nights I come off well is an advertisement: the archivist was told, and did not listen.
Leave a Reply